| NAME | YEAR | SPORT | LOCATION / AFFILIATION |
| Abitbol, Elke | 1986 | Masters – Running/Road Racing | Aurora |
| Barry, Ceal | 1986 | Coach of the Year – College | University of Colorado |
| Beitz, Jeannette | 1986 | Swimming | Fort Collins High School |
| Bell, Judy | 1986 | Dorothy Mauk Pioneer Award | Colorado Springs |
| Bhushan, Insook | 1986 | Table Tennis | Aurora |
| Burns, Joy | 1986 | Leadership | Denver |
| Busch, Shannon | 1986 | Running/Cross Country | Poudre High School |
| DeJong, Stacey | 1986 | AA Athlete of Year | Platte Valley High School |
| Dudek, Nicole | 1986 | Most Courageous | Heritage High School |
| Fischel, Vicki | 1986 | Bowling | Denver |
| Goldy, Cari | 1986 | Soccer | Cherry Creek High School |
| Hallee, Lisa | 1986 | Diving | Littleton |
| Hanssen, Kirsten | 1986 | Triathlon | Denver |
| Harsch, Kim | 1986 | Volleyball | San Diego State |
| Hill, Martha | 1986 | Skiing/Disabled | Winter Park |
| Houtchens, Haley | 1986 | Gymnastics | Eaton High School |
| Jacovetta, Denene | 1986 | Volleyball | Regis College |
| Johnson, Yolanda | 1986 | Track and Field | George Washington High School, CU |
| Jude, Erica | 1986 | Most Promising | Green Mountain High School |
| Kadavy, Caryn | 1986 | Skating/Figure | Colorado Springs |
| Lang, Valerie | 1986 | Swimming | Colorado State University |
| Long, Jami | 1986 | Volleyball | Overland High School |
| McCreery-Chamberlin, Judy | 1986 | Running/Road Racing | Golden |
| McMordie, Carol Ann | 1986 | Running/Cross Country | University of Colorado |
| Miles, Michelle | 1986 | Basketball | Thornton High School |
| Ohlsson, Mariza | 1986 | Masters All-Around | Denver |
| Pibulvech, Dang | 1986 | Special Achievement by a Coach | Colorado College |
| Randall, Michelle | 1986 | Softball | Wheat Ridge High School |
| Rios, Trina | 1986 | Most Courageous (with Anayansi Ricketts) | Sterling |
| Roe, Nancy | 1986 | Tennis | University of Northern Colorado |
| Schenk, Leslee | 1986 | Cycling | Boulder |
| Sixkiller, Fran | 1986 | Coach of the Year – High School | Lyons Jr./Sr. High School |
| Slade, Trisha | 1986 | A Athlete of Year | Sargent High School |
| Smith, Caryl | 1986 | Track and Field | George Washington High School |
| Szpara, Janine | 1986 | Soccer | Colorado College |
| Trenary, Jill | 1986 | Comeback | Cheyene Mountain High School |
| Trujillo, Juanita | 1986 | Powerlifting | Grand Junction |
| Turner, Bridget | 1986 | Basketball | University of Colorado |
| Urban, Patti | 1986 | Tennis | Smoky Hill High School |
| Whitworth, Becky | 1986 | Golf | Colorado Springs |
| Wolf, Cee | 1986 | Masters – Horsemanship | Littleton |